We must create a substitute for wars disciplinary function, something that will serve as the moral equivalent of war. Popular science monthlyvolume 77october 1910the moral. In fact, the ground war has actually begun before this was able to be sent out. William james considers substitutes for martial experience. Two questions raised by william jamess essay on the. Glenn gray, which had been given to me with a recommendation from one of the attendees of the nwtrcc conference earlier this month. On 25 february 1906, the eminent psychologist and philosopher william. Carter gave ten principles for the plan, but did not list specific actions. For the past fifteen years the movement for promoting international peace has been enlisting the support of organizations and individuals the world over. Then i declared the energy effort to be the moral equivalent of war, a phrase coined by william james and suggested to. Internet archive contributor internet archive language english. Apr 20, 1977 while james was merely speculating about the moral equivalent of war, about changing the attitudes of the people toward the state, president carter is actually thinking about putting these. The moral equivalent of war by wlliam james flashcards quizlet.
The moral equivalent of war the moral equivalent of war 1 the war against war is going to be no holiday excursion or camping party. Feb 22, 2015 president carters energy speech, april 1977. Although we wish to eliminate war, we value the virtues traditionally associated with military service. William jamess the moral equivalent of war modern man inherits all the innate pugnacity and all the love of glory of his ancestors. Mar 25, 2015 the moral equivalent of war james, william on. President carters remarks on joint statement at camp david summit video icon audio icon transcript icon. Introduction by jon roland to the moral equivalent of war by william james. In 1906, william james presented the moral equivalent of war and turned his attention to a question that has for better and for worse defined the american political landscape, namely, the question of how to maintain political unity and civic virtue in the absence of an immediate and galvanizing threat. This essay, based on a speech delivered at stanford university in 1906, is the origin of the idea of organized. The moral equivalent of war by william james full audiobook. So long as antimilitarists propose no substitute for wars disciplinary function, no moral equivalent of war, analogous, as one might say, to the mechanical equivalent of heat, so long they fail to realize the full inwardness of the situation. More concerned with the interiority of war than just war theory, james provides a modicum of guidance if not also consolation to those readers who object to war and forms of peace that mean the same. While james was merely speculating about the moral equivalent of war, about changing the attitudes of the people toward the state, president carter is. Youths might be conscripted to plant trees and build roads or dams rather than to kill the young men of other societies.
William james was an american philosopher and psychologist who is considered to be one of the greatest thinkers of the l. Moral equivalent of war how is moral equivalent of war. In the nineteenaughts, members of this large, vigorous movement held conferences, formed international. By closing this message, you are consenting to our use of cookies. The moral equivalent of war william james ecotopia.
Resources for sustainability the moral equivalent of war. Proposing the moral equivalent of war laphams quarterly. He submitted a comprehensive energy program to congress that was eventually reduced to an eviscerated corpse of carters original plan when it was passed. It is remembered as the speech where he compared the energy crisis with the moral equivalent of war. United states president jimmy carters moral equivalent of war speech was a speech in which carter addressed the united states on april 18, 1977. It is a matter of life and death, a road either to safety or to ruin. Just as military conscription provided basic economic security and instilled a sense of duty to confront a nations enemies, so james called for the draft of the whole youthful population to form for a certain number of. Start studying the moral equivalent of war by wlliam james. The moral equivalent of war by wlliam james flashcards. State of the union address video icon audio icon transcript icon september 17, 1978. His own suggestion is a conscription of youth, for a certain number of years, to work in various jobs all over the country in order to get the childishness knocked out of them and to come back into society with healthier.
The line of descent runs directly from this address to the depressionera civilian conservation corps to. William james, the moral equivalent of war, in the works of william james. So long as antimilitarists propose no substitute for war s disciplinary function, no moral equivalent of war, analogous, as one might say, to the mechanical equivalent of heat, so long they fail to realize the full inwardness of the situation. The military feelings are too deeply grounded to abdicate their place among our.
Sport is a good example of what william james meant by a moral equivalent of war an activity which satisfies similar psychological needs to war, and has a similar. And this one from a labor leader got to the heart of it. We must create a substitute for war s disciplinary function, something that will serve as the moral equivalent of war. The moral equivalent of war illustrated kindle edition by. William james on the moral equivalent of war andrew james. Project muse a call to arms militarism, political unity.
Hence it is a subject of inquiry which can on no account be neglected. In an incredible essay, the moral equivalent of war, first delivered as a talk at stanford and later published in 1910, the year of his death, james observes that though everyone would. Such programs would inoculate them with the same social vitamins as war without causing the same destruction to life and property. This difficult effort will be the moral equivalent of war, except that we will be uniting our efforts to build and not to destroy. Moral equivalence is a term used in political debate, usually to deny that a moral comparison can be made of two sides in a conflict, or in the actions or tactics of two sides.
James, in his 1906 essay, the moral equivalent of war, made the case for bringing the fervor we associate with war to improving civic life. Modern war was, james thought, too barbaric in itself to be considered a worthy means to any conceivable end. Pdf a call to arms militarism, political unity, and. A more recent reference is a 1977 speech by us president jimmy carter in which he compared the energy crisis with the moral equivalent of war. A moral equivalent of war and the pace chronic fatigue. We must deal with the energy problem on a war footing. Showing war s irrationality and horror is of no effect on him.
Barry freundel as i write today wednesday, july 16, the possibility of an israeli ground incursion into gaza has become more of a real possibility. The moral equivalent of war carter believed that solving the nations energy problem was this. The moral equivalent of war isbn 9781473365377 pdf epub. Librivox recording of the moral equivalent of war, by william james.
The war against war is going to be no holiday excursion or camping party. Many of these currents came together in william jamess 1910 essay, the moral equivalent of war, which was adapted from a lecture he had delivered at stanford university four years earlier. A century ago, william james spoke at stanford on the moral equivalent of war. The moral equivalent of war preparing ones self and. The line of descent runs directly from this address to the depressionera civilian conservation corps to the peace corps, vista, and americorps. But as marilyn fischer shows in her erudite contribution, reading the moral equivalent for war in historical. Already this domestic war has had many victories on many fronts throughout the world. If sport is a moral equivalent of war then it should be able to serve as a substitute for it, and to bring about a decline in warfare. In an incredible essay, the moral equivalent of war, first delivered as a talk at stanford and later published in 1910, the year of his death. The moral equivalent of war, a classic essay by based on a speech he delivered at stanford university in 1906.
William james, a committed pacifist, lived through the civil war and the spanishamerican war and died during the runup to world war i. The warriors picks up from william jamess moral equivalent of war yesterday i finished the warriors. The moral equivalent of war by william james this essay, based on a speech delivered at stanford university in 1906, is the origin of the idea of organized national service. Moral equivalent of war and on a certain blindness. The art of war, then, is governed by five constant factors, to be taken into account in ones. Jimmy carter a crisis of confidence speech american.
Two questions raised by william jamess essay on the moral equivalent of war volume 35 issue 2 julius seelye bixler skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. The military feelings are too deeply grounded to abdicate their place among our ideals until better substitutes are offered than the glory and shame that come to nations as well as to individuals from the ups and downs of politics and the vicissitudes of trade. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. William james on the moral equivalent of war andrew. The moral equivalent of war, the last public utterance of william james, is significant as expressing the opinions of a practical psychologist on a question of growing popular interest. This article on moral equivalent of war as a conflict resolution, by subhash mehta talks about the root causes of conflict which leads to violence and the role of education in eleminating conflict and violence to bring peace.
The war against war is going to be no holiday excursion or. This volume marks the 25th anniversary of the beginning of the quiet war. Nov 22, 2015 it comes from the title of his 1910 talk in which he called for a war against war that was going to be no holiday excursion or camping party. These ten days confirmed my belief in the decency and the strength and the wisdom of the american people, but it also bore out some of my longstanding concerns about. In 1910, as the worlds great powers were gearing up for a war with unprecedented destructive. This past spring and summer found the obama administration consumed with image management and damage control in response to the massive oil spill in the. This acclaimed book by william james is available at in several formats for your ereader. This classic essay by philosopher william james, published in 1910, was based on.
Sep 03, 20 the moral equivalent of war, the last public utterance of william james, is significant as expressing the opinions of a practical psychologist on a question of growing popular interest. On the moral equality of combatants rutgers university. Read the moral equivalent of war by william james available from rakuten kobo. The moral equivalent of war preparing ones self and family for an uncertain future. Sport is a good example of what william james meant by a moral equivalent of war an activity that satisfies similar psychological needs to war, and has a similar invigorating and socially. The moral equivalent of war illustrated kindle edition. William jamess widely read essay the moral equivalent of war 1910. The university of houston s college of engineering presents this series about the machines that make our civilization run, and the people whose ingenuity created them. The art of war is of vital importance to the state.
Jamess moral equivalent of war trygve throntveit jamess essay on the moral equivalent of war has long been read as either a quaintly naive plan to alter human nature through policy or an insidious scheme for perpetuating norms of male domination under the guise of service. The moral equivalent of war ebook by william james. News and opinion on peak oil, economic and environmental crises, and sustainability in a postcarbon world. Silent weapons for quiet wars although the silent weapons system was nearly exposed years later, the evolution of the new weaponsystem has never suffered any major setbacks. The term had some currency in polemic debates about the cold war, and currently the arabisraeli conflict. A call to arms militarism, political unity, and the moral equivalent of war. Address to the nation on energy video icon audio icon transcript icon january 19, 1978. The moral equivalent of war by william james free at. James considered one of the classic problems of politics. To learn about our use of cookies and how you can manage your cookie settings, please see our cookie policy.
Aug 03, 2015 william james, a committed pacifist, lived through the civil war and the spanishamerican war and died during the runup to world war i. James delivered an address entitled the moral equivalent of war at stan. Just as military conscription provided basic economic security and instilled a sense of duty to confront a nations enemies, so james called for the draft of the whole youthful population to form for a certain number of years a. This classic essay by philosopher william james, published in 1910, was based on a speech he delivered at stanford university in 1906. The moral equivalent of war essay by james britannica. Only when forced upon one, is a war now thought permissible. There is something highly paradoxical in the modern mans.
903 362 1462 723 421 773 713 425 127 40 945 494 1428 814 1273 382 541 609 1362 1397 1279 1330 855 640 935 712 1212 483 312 266 126 1397 600 260 572 517 170